Thursday, May 1, 2014

Paper Part 2

Confession until the Reformation
By the early 16th century, private personal confession in the Roman Catholic Church was seen as an evolved form of absolution. According to Gurrieri, canonical confession – or “second penance” (after baptism) – could be given only once in a sinner’s life, only by a bishop, and since it was not repeatable or portable, preferably as near to his death as possible. [1] Following that difficult-to-obtain once in a lifetime forgiveness, tariff penance, introduced by Irish/Anglo monks, was seen as an advance, being between a priest and the confessor and was repeatable and local. The good news was that confession was between priest and penitent, and did not involve the church; the bad news was that the priest could charge a tariff depending on the severity of the sin.[2] Sinners were literally paying for their sins.
By the middle ages, private confession was the most popular form remaining.[3] But how often should one confess? Moving from a tradition of once in a lifetime, the Fourth Lateran Council stated in 1215 that penitents were required – obliged – to go to confession at least once a year and that absolution by the priest was required for salvation.[4] Thomas Aquinas, upheld as late as 1551 at the Council of Trent, laid forth the four-part method of a sinner’s confession, the first three by the penitent – contrition, confession and satisfaction – and the last by the priest – absolution.[5] The Catholic Catechism of today in its Sacrament of Penance and Reconciliation retains this basic formula.[6]
The Absolution Reformation
  1. When our Lord and Master, Jesus Christ, said "Repent", He called for the entire life of believers to be one of repentance.
1st of Luther’s 95 Theses[7]
Of the many radical changes that came as a result of the Reformation – justification by grace through faith, the prominence of Scripture over tradition, the Bible translated into German, married clergy, the three solas, the emphasis on Law and Gospel, the wars fought, the priesthood of all believers, and eventually, a separate branch of Christianity apart from the influence of pope and councils – it is significant that it all began as a dissatisfaction over the practice of confession.[8] Kliefoth claimed that the Protestant Reformation was basically a restoration of Confession and Absolution.[9]
Luther’s problem with confession – and especially that of indulgences, or “monetary penalties substituted for performance penalties”[10] – was that it promoted a method of personally obtaining forgiveness of sins, a priesthood of tyrants who could forgive or withhold forgiveness on whim and an emphasis on human over Scriptural teachings.[11] These were no small problems, which he not only attacked in the 95 Theses, but The Babylonian Captivity of the Church (1520), and never more colorfully than in “On Confession: Whether the Pope has Power to Command It” (1521). Luther accused Pope Leo X of holding Christians hostage with his false gospel of human achievement. He called the pope The Antichrist who “breaks open the bridal chamber of Christ and makes all Christian souls into whores.”[12] Shocking language, but when one considers the biblical view of the church as the bride of Christ and that Christians were in a position to pay with money what Christ’s blood won for free, the metaphor is apt.
Absolution’s reform came in the form of freedom and frequency. Philip Melanchton, in the Augsburg Confession, states that private confession should be retained; that penitents are not required to enumerate their sin; their penance is not to be burdensome; indulgences and pilgrimages are not required; nor are they obliged to confess a certain number of times a year. On the other hand, absolution does require a believer’s faith, and absolution is required for communion (i.e. membership in the Christian church.) [13]
The Reformer’s greatest fear – that Christians, newly freed from the obligation to confess, would throw the confessional baby out with the papal bath water – came to pass. In 1529, Luther railed in his Large Catechism: “Unfortunately, people have learned it only too well; they do whatever they please and take advantage of their freedom, acting as if they should or need not go to confession anymore.”[14]
Luther’s pastors wanted to know further the kind of confessions that were available for their sinful flocks. Luther obliged in his Eighth Sermon to Wittenberg in which he enumerated three: a) a corporate confession before the congregation for public sins; b) confession directly to God for sins one committed against God alone; and c) private confession, in which “one takes another aside and tells him what troubles one, so that one may hear from him a word of comfort.”[15] Significantly, Luther does not say that this “another” needs to be clergy, implying that a Christian’s confessor need only be another Christian. He also states in this sermon that although this is the same kind commanded by the pope, he does not go to confession because the pope commands it. “Nevertheless I will allow no man to take private confession away from me, and I would not give it up for all the treasures in the world, since I know what comfort and strength it has given me.”[16] Luther saw private confession as one of many tools in one’s Absolution Toolbox: the promise of forgiveness from scripture, the Lord’s Prayer, baptism and private confession, for sins which one wants to confess “in secret.”[17]



[1], John A. Guerrieri, “Penance: A Brief Survey of a Problematic History,” in Whatever Happened to Private Confession,  Lutheran Forum, Vol. 31, No. 3, 1997, p. 26.
[2] Guerrieri, p 27
[3] Guerrieri, p. 28
[4] Gunther Gassmann and Scott Hendrix, Fortress Introduction to The Lutheran Confession, Fortress Press, Minneapolis, 1999, p. 101.
[5] ibid.
[6] Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2nd Edition, p. 324-5 (lines 1422-1424)
[7] Martin Luther, “Disputation on the Power and Efficacy of Indulgences Commonly Known as The 95 Theses,” Last modified 2011, accessed April 23, 2014, http://www.spurgeon.org/~phil/history/95theses.htm
[8] “The Reformation began with a call to reform the practice of repentance in the western church. The ministry of Jesus and his predecessor John started in the same way. John came ‘preaching a baptism of repentance for the forgiveness of sins.’ After his arrest, says Mark, ‘Jesus came preaching…repent and believe the Gospel’ (1:14f).” Edward H. Schroeder, “Baptism and Confession,” Trinity Seminary Review, Vol. 6, Issue 1, 1984, p 13.
[9] Brent W. Kuhlman, “ Holy Absolution: Rejoicing in the Gift,” in Whatever Happened to Private Confession,  Lutheran Forum, Vol. 31, No. 3, 1997, p. 29.
[10] Schroeder, p 16.
[11]Ronald K. Rittgers, “Luther on Private Confession,” Lutheran Quarterly, Volume XIX, 2005, p. 312.
[12] ibid.
[13] Gassmann and Hendrix, p. 102-04.
[14] Robert Kolb and Timothy J. Wengert, The Book of Concord: The Confessions of the Evangelical Lutheran Church, translated by Charles Arand, et al., Fortress Press, Minneapolis, 2000, p. 476.
[15] Martin Luther, "Eight Sermons at Wittenberg 1522," in 55-Volume American Edition Luther's Works on CD-RO, edited by Jaroslav Pelikan and Helmut T. Lehman, Volume 51: Sermons, Fortress Press Concordia Publishing House, 2002, p. 100.
[16] On the other hand, he wrote: “However, one who has a strong, firm faith that his sins are forgiven may let this confession go and confess to God alone. But how many have such a strong faith? Threrefore, as I have said, I will not let this private confession be take from me. But I will not have anybody forced to it, but left to each one’s free will.”  ibid.
[17] Luther, Eight Sermons, p. 99.

Paper part 1

Part 1 of my research paper on private personal confession.

Introduction and Thesis
            In our church, members may go years without saying, “I am a sinner” out loud, much less naming particular sins that trouble them to another.
            Our Savior Lutheran Tacoma is a contemporary and progressive Lutheran church which uses a liturgical format, but does not follow the traditional corporate confession outlined in the Lutheran Service Book.[1] Instead, our Pastor expertly employs the theme for the day into a very specific confession of sins, thinking that this is much more effective in getting his congregation to hear and think about particular sins they have committed, rather than the corporate form, which he has found ineffective.[2]
            Nevertheless, members may go years without saying, “I am a sinner” out loud, much less naming particular sins that trouble them to another.
Few Lutherans would argue that the most significant event in Christian history in the past 500 years was Luther’s Reformation of the Western Church. Few Lutherans would argue, upon reflection, that the catalyst for the Reformation had to do with absolution. Few rue, however, the fading in prominence of a key component of absolution in Luther’s time, private personal confession of one’s sins. For a variety of reasons – but especially because early Lutheran reformers could not agree on its place inside or outside the sacramental realm – private confession is rarely practiced today. Analysis of select passages that identify the disintegration of the practice of private confession reveals its erosion is of secondary importance to its failure to be practiced today. I will argue that the Lutheran priesthood of all believers should consider returning private confession from obscurity to its rightful place: not as a Third Sacrament, but as one of many tools in our Absolution Toolbox.



[1] “Most merciful God, we confess that we are by nature sinful and unclean. We have sinned against you in thought, word, and deed, by what we have done and by what we have left undone. We have not loved you with our whole heart, we have not loved our neighbor as ourselves. We justly deserve your temporal and eternal punishment. For the sake of Your Son, Jesus Christ, have mercy on us. Forgive us, renew us, and lead us, so that we may delight in your will and walk in Your ways to the glory of Your holy name. Amen.” Lutheran Service Book, Concordia Publishing House, St. Louis, 2006, p. 151.
[2] private conversation with Rev. Brian Banke.

Wednesday, April 30, 2014

impious

For the past three weeks, I've been listening to a recording of Eusebius' Church History. This is a very important book, especially for historians and church historians in particular. It is not delightful. But I've noticed that there is a word that he loves to use, and I love to hear.
Impious (not pious :  lacking in reverence or proper respect (as for God or one's parents) :  irreverent
To wit:

  • and that he impiously sets forth this error of his in detail, holding that the Deity is unknowable and incomprehensible.
  • he certainly did not do it on account of his entertaining the impious notion of that man,
  • Those who share in this heresy do not allow images, as the impious Severus did not
  • Then returning he came to Jericho, where, being seized with melancholy, he planned to commit an impious deed, as if challenging death itself. 
  • The king did not rebuke them, nor did he reject their impious flattery
  • we practiced unlawful commerce with mothers and sisters, and enjoyed impious feasts.
  • and thus through their lawless and impious teaching under pretense of grace, have sunk to the lowest depths of perdition
Apparently, there was a lot of impious behavior in Eusebius' time. 115 times the word is mentioned in his 1000 page tome. And yet no matter how much calumnious behavior E was describing, the pronunciation of the word takes away from the meaning of the word. When I hear impious pronounced correctly IMP-eous it carries with it not heretical or damnable behavior - it implies (!) mischievous behavior - the behavior of an imp (but not the Game of Thrones' Imp, (below) who is a leader in impious behavior.) I hear "naughty" when it is pronounced this way, like Jon Lovitz' "Tales of Ribaldry." 
The secondary pronunciation - a lot less fun to say - actually conveys the meaning of the word: im-PIE-us, emphasizing the very opposite of piety.
Pronunciation belies the meaning. Would you rather have a word that's fun to say but changes the meaning, or mispronounce and be understood perfectly?




Peter Dinklage, the impious Imp.


Monday, April 28, 2014

Billy Bob Goes to Westeros and gets religion

My primary viewing this week was the new Fargo TV series, along with Game of Thrones and Battlestar Galactica. I'm surprised that the most God-talk does not come from the series set in the Midwest, or in a mythical land of lords and ladies but from outer space.
Can I just say that God looks good in a red dress?
BG was pitched to me as a being pretty religious, but who knew? I have a funny feeling that the believers in the one true God are not going to fare well in this series, as the ones who believe in the one true God who offers forgiveness in exchange for a personal relationship with him are "toasters," in the vocabulary of the show. The Cylons are robots that humans created and have rebelled, and although they originally looked like the Cybermen from Dr. Who (see below comparison), they have no figured out how to look like us, and in fact have flesh and blood. And they believe in one God, while the majority of the humans believe in the Lords of Kobol, which are a lot like Greek and Roman gods. I look forward to learning more about other's religions, even if they are by blind believers in a God we share. Could be awkward.
Then there's GoT (see, I'm getting the hang of being cool), which I'm learning more about. I did make one good call from last week's column, and that was that Lady Stark is not to be toyed with. She knows how to marshal sympathy against her enemies, and quick. (The last I've seen her is surrounding the bad writer from Elf with loyal swords. Very nice.)
As much as we are loving Fargo, after two shows, we are suspending our watch because of too many ding dang commercials on Comcast. It took 1:15 to watch a 40 minute show. Good job, Comcast - you've lost two viewers. Sometimes on Xfinity, they'll only show one or maybe two commercials, like on Parks and Rec or The Middle. But man oh man, the "content" feels more like a break from the commercials, instead of the other way around.
Ironically, the most interesting thing I watched about religion this week was in The Americans, which is frankly one of the better shows on television. Thank you F/X (which also gives us the amazing Walton Goggin's brand of southern creepy religion in Justified). The short story on The Americans is that Elizabeth and Philip Jennings, travel agent couple living next door to any one of us, with two kids are deeply embedded KGB agents during the Reagan era. Had this show been on during the 80s, everyone would have been paranoid that their next door neighbors were KGB agents. (As one who lived during that time, I believe that was the thought that Reagan was cultivating). Anyway, just like in The Good Wife, the teen age daughter has found religion, and committed 600 of her hard-earned dollars to go on a mission trip. Remember, her parents are "godless communists" and so the thought that they are actually bringing their own two kids (who don't know their parents' real lives) up as followers of the opiate of the masses sends dad and mom into freak out mode, but dad more than mom. Dad rips pages out of the Bible and screams "So your Jesus tells you to lie to your parents?" He later goes to her pastor and threatens him with physical harm if he ever goes near their daughter again.
I think I'll show that scene at the next DCE meeting when one of my fellow youth directors complains about "alligator parents."
I'm finishing up Hitchcock's 39 Steps and will soon be done with Dovzhenko's Earth (1930), which has this great opening scene...
Old man reposing.
Old friend says, "You dyin' Simon?"
Old man says, "That I am, Peter."
Old friend looks around, sees peaches growing, young men smiling, owheat fields blowing, children playing. Says, "Yep. Well go ahead."

File:Cyberman 2013.jpg

Friday, April 25, 2014

The week in review 4

Stillness: Recalling God's Presence
The clear winner and champeen of all time is Easter morning prayer vigil. I've had the 5 am - 6 am slot since 2005, and it's especially what I look forward to each year, especially now that I'm not concerned about the Easter Breakfast anymore. The chapel is an especial blessed place to do it (when there's no one using the bathroom, that is!) The past two years, I've been Facebook Praying, reaching out to people I think would be open to hearing a particular Easter prayer. And I pray for my family and Vanguard, of course, since they are those closest to my heart.

Gratitude: Expressing Thankfulness 
I'm thankful for my friend Doug. He's taken a call to a Lutheran church in Spokane, and, apart from my four year stint in Canada, he has been the DCE closest to me. He'll still be in the same state, but since my DCE days are waning, I probably won't see him too much more. He's a great dude and will be missed.

Reflection: Looking Back on Your Day 
Another good Friday, highlighted by some Battlestar Galactica. I finished the pilot and two shows today. Well, I wouldn't say that's the highlight,which is my continuing paper on private confession, which I hope to publish in this space next week. Such an interesting topic. Graced by my wife's presence this afternoon, which was a treat. She is being feted as one of the two new hires in the PLU religion department tonight, so I took the chance to play some indoor/outdoor frisbee at the Puyallup Y. Such a duffer, but I did get some great exercise. And I didn't get hurt, which is a bonus. Shout out to Trader Joes, the best grocery store on earth. They had some spicy sausage sampler today that was very tasty! And I got to mow the lawn for the first time in two weeks; nearly machete height. For these and all blessings, I thank you God!

Sorrow: Asking for Forgiveness
Each Friday is a good day to remember Good Friday. This week's sins that helped nail Christ to the cross: I had my evaluation at church, and everyone said really nice things about me, but I sometimes don't feel completely at home at OSLC; I feel like I'm a burden, old youth director and all. It's when I am forced to look at what I do that I feel like I'm falling short of God's purpose.

Hopefulness: Resolving to Grow
My hopefulness this week is in my 2014 ministry plan, which should include more school visits and being part of a killer small group. Can't tell you how pumped I am about that. Despite my round minister in a square church feeling from above, i am hopeful for the next year. I look forward to the small group, confirmation and youth events taking a positive turn. I'm hopeful for this summer's courses - Writings of the Mystics and Pastoral Counseling. I think that should prove pretty cool, and hopefully practical for the situation I find myself in at OSLC.

Thursday, April 24, 2014

Icon

Our subject in Images of God this week was icons, but the subject actually came up the week before in a post by one of the four guys in my sub-group. (in order to build a closer relationship throughout the term, the prof subdivided us into groups of four and five. This helps draw us closer; that, and the Voodoo doughnuts I bought during our face time cemented it.) The lesson was from C. Baxter Kruger's The Great Dance: Christian Vision Revisited which teaches us that God has invited us to an amazing dance, and that we have become so enamored of our own sinfulness that we have forgotten that the purpose behind the savior was to invite us to the Eden Dance, not to have a kid save us from an abusive parent. We were all moved by this image, of an inviting God, but one of us was terrified by the prospect. He said the reading made him think of Rublev's icon of the Trinity: 
This is truly one of the most incredible creations by any human being, but it was a source of anxiety for our group, because we realize that there's no kid's table. We are to be seated with the father, son and holy spirit. We are in the game, and that can be a lot less comfortable than sitting at the next table in adoration. In order to make him feel better about it, I used my awesome Microsoft Paint skills to come up with this:


I can't believe I even forgot to click off so that John still has the editing square around him. Sorry John!

That's our little motley crew, chillin' at the Trinity's table. I do not mean to disrespect a work of art I greatly admire, but I hope it helped a fella in crisis. I think it did cheer us all a bit, to think that we are invited to the table, to the dance, to the wedding - whichever metaphor you would like to employ. I love how lovingly each member is looking at these obvious interlopers. Better to photoshop in the pope or Mother Theresa. 
But then I thought, no, this is exactly what I wanted to say, that none of us belong at God's table, and no matter how perfect we try to be, and how many souls we save and how many mouths we feed, we are still not good enough to be at that table.
But we were invited; and that makes all the difference. We may not sit at the right hand of the father, but we may get to visit; won't that be amazing!
So this week's reading was actually on icons; we read an article by Jim Foster, who used - guess what? - the Rublev as an example of the highest form of the art. He said it is a corridor to heaven, not in a real way, but in a transformative way. We look at this icon, and see the reality of heaven.
Same with mine. See you there in 50 years, guys!

Wednesday, April 23, 2014