God bless you, Ted Turner, and your classic movies.
Discovered last week that I can cross a couple of my films off the 1001 Movies list by searching Turner Classic Movie's on demand selections. Over the last week, I've watched In the Heat of the Night ("They call me MISTER Tibbs.") White Heat ("Top of the world, Ma!"), Picnic at Hanging Rock ("Absolutely no catch phrase!") and today, Marty, which won a slew of Academy Awards, including one for McHale. That's how I knew Ernest Borgnine growing up, that and that he was in Willard, the rat movie which spawned the Michael Jackson love song. To a rat, not Ernest Borgnine. I was knocked over by Marty, which is the story of how a mom-pecked, friend-pecked and culture-pecked Italian butcher is able to find love at the Stardust Ballroom by taking the high road. It is an incredibly charming slice of life film. In no way would it be an Oscar winning film today, but it certainly is a simply-told tale of one really good 48 hour period in 1950s New York.
The other film I watched was Peter "Green Card" Weir's Picnic at Hanging Rock, which is about the real life turn of the last century disappearance of three teens and their teacher at a mysterious rock formation in the Australian outback. No gore, no sex, no violence, no overt thrills, but yet it elicits all of those emotions with good old fashioned story telling. Besides, it is a real life mystery, so there is no resolution, and not even any theories. But it does have Zamfir, master of the pan flute.
Also saw a couple of films on Hulu (though finding an actual free movie is pretty tough.) They have a whole section of Criterion Collection films. If my rich uncle died and left me a million bucks I'd be sad for the fictirious rich uncle, of course, but after paying back all of my family's student debt, I would sink some money into purchasing the entire Criterion Collection. These are the finest films ever made, beautifully restored. At any rate, one of them happens to be Gertrude, which is 2 hours of Norwegian angst. The actors barely look at each other during their loooooong bouts of dialogue, about how love is unhappiness, love is pain etc. It's by Carl Dreyer, who did the spectacular Passion of Joan of Arc about 40 years earlier. It got to be very Dieter after awhile. Also from Hulu, I saw the Evil Dead (now Cabin in the Woods makes sense!) and Boudou Saved from Drowning (pretty amusing) and Killing of a Chinese Bookie (important. not especially fun.)
Great week of film, for the most part. I'm getting pretty good and forestalling the necessity for Netflix!
Monday, May 12, 2014
Wednesday, May 7, 2014
Irenic
These are some quotations I found from a word that I read in
my Christian history book.
Irenic:
adjective
formal
adjective: irenic; adjective: eirenic
1
aiming or aimed at peace.
2
noun
noun: irenics; noun: eirenics;
noun: irenic; noun: eirenic
a part of Christian theology concerned with reconciling
different denominations and sects.
- From a Symposium of The Seven Trumpets of Rev. 8&9. What little of value that could be gained from the Bible could be ascertained from reason itself….Spinoza's mode of textualization was IRENIC because it embedded the Bible in ancient history, where it would no longer be able to trouble modern life…
- In Explorations in the Theology of Pope Benedict XVI, in a chapter written by Francesca Murphy. "This essay is a reflection on a "papal ecclesiology" conducted in an irenic and ecumenical spirit."
- In his article "Biblical Authority: A Personal Reflection," Prof. Walter Brueggemann states that at Eden Seminary "there was no systematic theologian on the faculty until 1946, and things were managed well enough in a mood of trustful piety that produced not hard-nosed certitude, but rather an irenic charity of liberated generosity."
Then I found a critique of a critique of a pastor my pastor
likes, Tim Keller, by theweeflea.
Firstly I am always
wary of the person who comes to talk to me and begins the conversation with ‘I
want to tell you this in love’. It usually means that there is a
broadside to follow and very little love accompanying it. The ‘I want to
tell you in love’ is really a self-justification for the particular complaint
they are about to offload on you. I’m afraid it is much the same
here. The authors talk about their ‘respect’ for Keller and then accuse
him of wrong teaching and harm on some pretty important subjects. I
suspect that Tim Keller, like most of us, would rather do without that kind of
irenic grace! In this case actions speak louder than words. I
am reminded of those who came to Jesus and began by stating “teacher we know
you are a man of integrity and that you teach the way of God in accordance with
the truth.” (Matthew 22:16), before they then went on to try and trap him.
Working on the principle of ‘do unto others’ perhaps each of the authors
would like to reflect on how they would feel if fellow ministers were
publishing books which accuse them of not teaching the full orbed Word of God?
Secondly if Keller is
guilty of misleading the church about hell, creation, the Bible, evangelism,
apologetics, the social gospel, sin and the trinity, then why bother being
‘irenic’ about it? Was Jesus irenic when he called the Pharisees ‘white
washed tombs’? Can you imagine Paul saying to the Galatian false
teachers, ‘I say this to you in a spirit of irenic love and graciousness, if
you insist on circumcision, I wish you would go the whole way and castrate
yourselves!’ The trouble is that the authors of this book are playing the
modern Christian game – as long as you say it nicely and appear to be nice
(gracious,irenic, loving) etc then you can say what you want.
Personally I find this both somewhat disingenuous and pathetic. If Keller
is dangerous then just say so. Don’t hide it in modern reformed
christianspeak.
I want to know more about his book and the responses!
I was inspired to use this word on my Fbook page today. Yes,
I know - it's more than one sentence, and might have even eclipsed the 140
character gold standard of brevity - but here it is:
Why is history
important?
The term "denomination" started in the US during Wesley's Evangelical Revival as a form of tolerance among religious people who were "denominated" within the united body of Christianity. While we think of denominations as divisive, denominations were a way to say, "We are united in the body of Christ, even while we respectfully disagree with some of your doctrines."
So if denominations were formed to unite Christianity...what does that make non-denominational churches!
Ironic/irenic.
The term "denomination" started in the US during Wesley's Evangelical Revival as a form of tolerance among religious people who were "denominated" within the united body of Christianity. While we think of denominations as divisive, denominations were a way to say, "We are united in the body of Christ, even while we respectfully disagree with some of your doctrines."
So if denominations were formed to unite Christianity...what does that make non-denominational churches!
Ironic/irenic.
I used the word before I knew the second meaning of it, but
it did come from the section on Pietism, so it does make sense that there is a
field of study on how denominations can become more peaceful, come together,
unite in Christian love called irenics. I’m also aware of how ironic my
troll-worthy passage is; I’m not outright telling our non-denom brothers and
sisters that they are, by definition, against peace in the church, but there it
is. Probably a product of my being in a class of primarily non-denom seminarians!
Again, the word came to mind as I heard our speaker tonight,
Dennis Trittin offer a challenge to the jr and sr high youth of our church to
take the integrity challenge: for one week, only say or write things that are
either neutral or positive.
In other words, be irenic.
Tuesday, May 6, 2014
Softball
I have a love/hate relationship with church softball.
On the one hand (the uninjured hand), I love the game, the guys I play with, the exercise I get running after balls. I love when the bat makes good contact with the ball (as it did twice tonight) and racing around the bases. We have this year a crazy entertaining pitcher, who sometimes pitches between his legs and dances around the pitching rubber as if it hooked up to electrodes. We are a weird team, almost evenly split between lefties and righties. I love how we have a good team spirit and how we pray after every game with our "foes."
On the other hand (the injured hand), I hate how my body aches like it didn't used to, how it takes me longer to get to first base, how my skills seemed to have sunk rapidly since I first started playing nine years ago. Time was, I was "triple Tim," who could scuttle around the bases like nobody's business. Now I'm happy if I get to first base. Time was, if I touched it, I caught it. Now I'm lucky if I catch it at all, even if it's right in my glove.And speaking of injuries, I've had season-ending injuries two years in a row. One was awesome - I pulled my hamstring making a game-ending, game-saving diving catch against the Mormons! Probably get a two-planet demotion for that, but it felt good, even though - and this is the worst part - that I was hobbled for another month, including the only time I got to play Ultimate frisbee in my home town with my relatives. I wanted to be in peak condition for that, but I played like an old man. They all still think I'm fair to mediocre. And then last year was the worst. As I was trying to hit a fairly well-hit pop up, I put up two hands to catch - like you do, with my right hand giving stability to my glove hand - and instead of the ball landing in my glove, it landed on top of my right middle finger, breaking it. Not only that, but I tried to drive myself to the hospital, and almost passed out on the way from shock.
Never again! I said. Especially since I just now finished paying for it.
So there I am out in right center field feeling a mixture of fear and trembling with excitement to be playing again. All for God and glory - and the glory of God, right?
I like that our sleeve says "Love God, Love people and Live like Jesus." But that has also has not always been the case, especially against the Lutherans.
Yes, I know we're Lutheran too, but up until last year, we were never able to beat them. So that rankled. The reason? They had some pretty non-church league players anchoring their line-up. They had three home run hitters, and when you can count on three runs each inning, that sort of puts you in an advantageous position. Our captain, my captain, sent a well-crafted letter to the pastor of the other church saying that their team was a bad witness to the other teams, who saw them as bullies. After all, they had not lost a game in six years. He suggested that the players who were their D-Rec players play in the D-Rec league and not in the church league. They agreed, midway through last season, and our team was the church champion! Yay us.
Here's the thing though - now we are the church team that probably won't lose any games this season. We have several players who don't go to our church, who have played for other church's teams that no longer have teams. So we're almost kind of the all-star team in the league; I've never been comfortable in the Goliath position.
So I thought "cookies." That's one way to be less of the 800 pound gorilla in the league, is by also being the kindest team in the league. So after we're done pummeling our opponents, we give them something sweet. I don't mind winning; I do mind being resented.
There's a difference between being the best team in the league, and being the giant undefeated team in the league who pulls in ringers from all corners in order to be the giant in the league. I want to be known as the kindest team in the league, and that will take some doing.
On the one hand (the uninjured hand), I love the game, the guys I play with, the exercise I get running after balls. I love when the bat makes good contact with the ball (as it did twice tonight) and racing around the bases. We have this year a crazy entertaining pitcher, who sometimes pitches between his legs and dances around the pitching rubber as if it hooked up to electrodes. We are a weird team, almost evenly split between lefties and righties. I love how we have a good team spirit and how we pray after every game with our "foes."
On the other hand (the injured hand), I hate how my body aches like it didn't used to, how it takes me longer to get to first base, how my skills seemed to have sunk rapidly since I first started playing nine years ago. Time was, I was "triple Tim," who could scuttle around the bases like nobody's business. Now I'm happy if I get to first base. Time was, if I touched it, I caught it. Now I'm lucky if I catch it at all, even if it's right in my glove.And speaking of injuries, I've had season-ending injuries two years in a row. One was awesome - I pulled my hamstring making a game-ending, game-saving diving catch against the Mormons! Probably get a two-planet demotion for that, but it felt good, even though - and this is the worst part - that I was hobbled for another month, including the only time I got to play Ultimate frisbee in my home town with my relatives. I wanted to be in peak condition for that, but I played like an old man. They all still think I'm fair to mediocre. And then last year was the worst. As I was trying to hit a fairly well-hit pop up, I put up two hands to catch - like you do, with my right hand giving stability to my glove hand - and instead of the ball landing in my glove, it landed on top of my right middle finger, breaking it. Not only that, but I tried to drive myself to the hospital, and almost passed out on the way from shock.
Never again! I said. Especially since I just now finished paying for it.
So there I am out in right center field feeling a mixture of fear and trembling with excitement to be playing again. All for God and glory - and the glory of God, right?
I like that our sleeve says "Love God, Love people and Live like Jesus." But that has also has not always been the case, especially against the Lutherans.
Yes, I know we're Lutheran too, but up until last year, we were never able to beat them. So that rankled. The reason? They had some pretty non-church league players anchoring their line-up. They had three home run hitters, and when you can count on three runs each inning, that sort of puts you in an advantageous position. Our captain, my captain, sent a well-crafted letter to the pastor of the other church saying that their team was a bad witness to the other teams, who saw them as bullies. After all, they had not lost a game in six years. He suggested that the players who were their D-Rec players play in the D-Rec league and not in the church league. They agreed, midway through last season, and our team was the church champion! Yay us.
Here's the thing though - now we are the church team that probably won't lose any games this season. We have several players who don't go to our church, who have played for other church's teams that no longer have teams. So we're almost kind of the all-star team in the league; I've never been comfortable in the Goliath position.
So I thought "cookies." That's one way to be less of the 800 pound gorilla in the league, is by also being the kindest team in the league. So after we're done pummeling our opponents, we give them something sweet. I don't mind winning; I do mind being resented.
There's a difference between being the best team in the league, and being the giant undefeated team in the league who pulls in ringers from all corners in order to be the giant in the league. I want to be known as the kindest team in the league, and that will take some doing.
Monday, May 5, 2014
Walk on Water
We have tv friends and we have movie friends. Our tv friends watch tv series with us - we've watched Slings and Arrows , Episodes and now Bored to Death together, and they've all been enjoyable. We've had these friends for three years; it takes us awhile. We also love talking about the shows we like, and the next shows we're going to watch together.
Then we have our movie friends, and so far, we've watched five movies: Casino Royale, From Russia with Love (from them) and The White Balloon and Frankenstein (from us). It was there turn again this weekend, and, inspired by the Iranian descent of The White Balloon, our friends showed us Walk on Water, from Israel. P is right in saying that it is a movie that beggars categorization. It's certainly a drama, but also has to do with homophobia, Nazis, the Mossad spy agency of Israel and communes. And, the one thing everyone remembers about this film is the resurrecction of a long-dead Eurovision Song contest winner, Rockefeller Cinderella, an ear worm that rivals Mannah-mannah, 500 Miles and the Candy Man combined.
The plot is pretty simple - a Mossad agent who's had a trauma has been assigned to shadow the grandchildren of an alleged Nazi. If and when he learns information from them, he's supposed to alert his bosses who will probably kill him "before God does."
Like the White Balloon, this is definitely not a Hollywood spy story - there's no chases, or exciting music, or dramatic twists - it's a story that's told simply without straying and without true fantasy, though some would say the ending has fantastic elements (but don't all dreams?) Ironic, isnt't it, that a film called Walk on Water could be real! The more I watch movies from other countries - and in particular from the Middle East - the less I become excited about our American product. The last Hollywood movie I saw was Captain America; I'm looking forward to Godzilla, and I think I'm ready to see iconic American buildings being destroyed. I think this is probably a way for filmmakers to tap into the psyche of Americans who are barely a decade from getting used to the Twin Towers being destroyed, but just stop and think how many times you've seen the White House destroyed, or the Golden Gate Bridge. It's insulting, frankly. It's as if filmmakers don't trust us to feel anything except the most extreme destruction of our most treasured places. They sit in their offices and think of different ways to capture our heart, when all they have to do is think what it felt like to lose a lot of money that your parents gave you (it could be as much as 10 dollars!) My heart is no longer moved by the site of destroyed buildings; the best moment of the Avengers is the after-credit scene of them eating shawarma, sort of breathing heavy, sipping soda, not talking, thinking about all the creatures they'd destroyed. It was the most human, marvelous moment in the Marvel universe; not Tony Stark's house falling into the ocean, not Manhatten getting destroyed yet again by a maniacal alien.
The opposite conceit is what I call the "incredible normal" movies of Wes Anderson and Woody Allen, movies that pretend to be real, but are peopled by people I've never met. True, I've never met Woody Allen, and if I had, I would probably say, "Oh, now this all makes sense." Nor am I enamored of the realism of the French New Wave or the German Expressionist movement, or the dogme style, which is so "true" it rings false. This seems more like a one-off blog, so perhaps I'll come back to this at a later time.
But as you watch films, stop yourself and think "Come on. Is this true?" Regardless, people still go into the basement, they still walk down dark alleys and, according to movies, the only really good sex begins with being slammed against a wall, a floor, a table. It must be something hard, and there must be a struggle to get the clothes off.
So tedious.
Mike Leigh. Real and interesting. There, I named an English speaking director who takes reality seriously. Go see a Mike Leigh movie today.
Then we have our movie friends, and so far, we've watched five movies: Casino Royale, From Russia with Love (from them) and The White Balloon and Frankenstein (from us). It was there turn again this weekend, and, inspired by the Iranian descent of The White Balloon, our friends showed us Walk on Water, from Israel. P is right in saying that it is a movie that beggars categorization. It's certainly a drama, but also has to do with homophobia, Nazis, the Mossad spy agency of Israel and communes. And, the one thing everyone remembers about this film is the resurrecction of a long-dead Eurovision Song contest winner, Rockefeller Cinderella, an ear worm that rivals Mannah-mannah, 500 Miles and the Candy Man combined.
The plot is pretty simple - a Mossad agent who's had a trauma has been assigned to shadow the grandchildren of an alleged Nazi. If and when he learns information from them, he's supposed to alert his bosses who will probably kill him "before God does."
Like the White Balloon, this is definitely not a Hollywood spy story - there's no chases, or exciting music, or dramatic twists - it's a story that's told simply without straying and without true fantasy, though some would say the ending has fantastic elements (but don't all dreams?) Ironic, isnt't it, that a film called Walk on Water could be real! The more I watch movies from other countries - and in particular from the Middle East - the less I become excited about our American product. The last Hollywood movie I saw was Captain America; I'm looking forward to Godzilla, and I think I'm ready to see iconic American buildings being destroyed. I think this is probably a way for filmmakers to tap into the psyche of Americans who are barely a decade from getting used to the Twin Towers being destroyed, but just stop and think how many times you've seen the White House destroyed, or the Golden Gate Bridge. It's insulting, frankly. It's as if filmmakers don't trust us to feel anything except the most extreme destruction of our most treasured places. They sit in their offices and think of different ways to capture our heart, when all they have to do is think what it felt like to lose a lot of money that your parents gave you (it could be as much as 10 dollars!) My heart is no longer moved by the site of destroyed buildings; the best moment of the Avengers is the after-credit scene of them eating shawarma, sort of breathing heavy, sipping soda, not talking, thinking about all the creatures they'd destroyed. It was the most human, marvelous moment in the Marvel universe; not Tony Stark's house falling into the ocean, not Manhatten getting destroyed yet again by a maniacal alien.
The opposite conceit is what I call the "incredible normal" movies of Wes Anderson and Woody Allen, movies that pretend to be real, but are peopled by people I've never met. True, I've never met Woody Allen, and if I had, I would probably say, "Oh, now this all makes sense." Nor am I enamored of the realism of the French New Wave or the German Expressionist movement, or the dogme style, which is so "true" it rings false. This seems more like a one-off blog, so perhaps I'll come back to this at a later time.
But as you watch films, stop yourself and think "Come on. Is this true?" Regardless, people still go into the basement, they still walk down dark alleys and, according to movies, the only really good sex begins with being slammed against a wall, a floor, a table. It must be something hard, and there must be a struggle to get the clothes off.
So tedious.
Mike Leigh. Real and interesting. There, I named an English speaking director who takes reality seriously. Go see a Mike Leigh movie today.
Sunday, May 4, 2014
The week in review part 5
Stillness: Recalling God's Presence
I noticed God's presence in our youth frisbee game Wednesday. Seniors Kelsey, Anders and Seth were there, along with Tyler from last year. Play a familiar game with old friends and new was a happy occurrence; I've done so many things the past four years with these particular group of people, it would require a yearly examen to catalogue them all. I was able to make a photographic memory for Kelsey this week, and it really did take me back. And I had dinner with her Wednesday - this is a young woman who is going places, and yet incredibly close to the Lord's path. She's a keeper, and I see the presence of God in her entire presence.
Gratitude: Expressing Thankfulness
See below.
Reflection: Looking Back on Your Day
I'm writing this on Sunday, and it was a big up and down day. It started with the Splash Leader's meeting, and there's currently a bit of confusion over how to proceed with the next steps in our Splash Group's life. Do we keep the 9th graders together as one big group, or do we integrate them into groups by existing leaders? Then the confirmands-to-be came and we went over their statements of belief. Not to be missed next weekend! There are some very good and personal statements of belief. We should all be so proud. 10:30 service was a downer - we only had 7 people, and that includes the pianist and me. I don't have a good feeling about the future of the traditions service. Then I met with a young man who has decided, after two years in confirmation, that he does not want to go through with it. He does not want to stand before his peers and parents and say things that he doesn't believe in. Honestly, I would prefer someone like this than someone who stands up there and goes through the motions, never intending to make faith in God part of their life. So it was sad for him - he felt like he was disappointing his mom - and his mom and brother - who felt sad that he felt sad. Tears all around. Great family. He'll be fine. Bought a computer for my daughter, went home and took the obligatory Sunday nap; got up and hauled some cheap pavers from my neighbor's estate sale then played frisbee for about 45 minutes. Normally, standing in the rain in sweatpants is not a pleasant thing, but I had a really good time; and I saw an osprey with a fish in its beak. So that was cool. But the highlight was definitely our dinner and evening worship small group inaugural event at the H-Es house. We sat and talked about what it might look like to be a traditional Lutheran based small group. We also discovered that three of us have a Kalamazoo connection - Joel was raised there, Gretchen moved there, I was on an journalism internship there. And I got my first cat there, Maud. Apart from that, we shared a nice evening worship service from the blue hymnal. We've slated May 18 as the next one. We're going to draw on each other's expertise and different devotionals. So that'll be great. And my wife's cookies were a hit!
Sorrow: Asking for Forgiveness
I continually forget that I have a "congregation" that will need to receive my personal touch. We had very few people today, and part of that is because I have not kept up with my worshipping community. I'll be making some calls this week.
Hopefulness: Resolving to Grow
I'm hopeful that I can convey the wonder and beauty of our church's history through the Equip classes this week. The last 500 years have been very important, I think, in the history of the world, and we'll be talking about several men and women who have played an important part in the furthering of the kingdom of God on earth. I'm hopeful about the ministry plan that will come together this month. To God be the glory.
I noticed God's presence in our youth frisbee game Wednesday. Seniors Kelsey, Anders and Seth were there, along with Tyler from last year. Play a familiar game with old friends and new was a happy occurrence; I've done so many things the past four years with these particular group of people, it would require a yearly examen to catalogue them all. I was able to make a photographic memory for Kelsey this week, and it really did take me back. And I had dinner with her Wednesday - this is a young woman who is going places, and yet incredibly close to the Lord's path. She's a keeper, and I see the presence of God in her entire presence.
Gratitude: Expressing Thankfulness
See below.
Reflection: Looking Back on Your Day
I'm writing this on Sunday, and it was a big up and down day. It started with the Splash Leader's meeting, and there's currently a bit of confusion over how to proceed with the next steps in our Splash Group's life. Do we keep the 9th graders together as one big group, or do we integrate them into groups by existing leaders? Then the confirmands-to-be came and we went over their statements of belief. Not to be missed next weekend! There are some very good and personal statements of belief. We should all be so proud. 10:30 service was a downer - we only had 7 people, and that includes the pianist and me. I don't have a good feeling about the future of the traditions service. Then I met with a young man who has decided, after two years in confirmation, that he does not want to go through with it. He does not want to stand before his peers and parents and say things that he doesn't believe in. Honestly, I would prefer someone like this than someone who stands up there and goes through the motions, never intending to make faith in God part of their life. So it was sad for him - he felt like he was disappointing his mom - and his mom and brother - who felt sad that he felt sad. Tears all around. Great family. He'll be fine. Bought a computer for my daughter, went home and took the obligatory Sunday nap; got up and hauled some cheap pavers from my neighbor's estate sale then played frisbee for about 45 minutes. Normally, standing in the rain in sweatpants is not a pleasant thing, but I had a really good time; and I saw an osprey with a fish in its beak. So that was cool. But the highlight was definitely our dinner and evening worship small group inaugural event at the H-Es house. We sat and talked about what it might look like to be a traditional Lutheran based small group. We also discovered that three of us have a Kalamazoo connection - Joel was raised there, Gretchen moved there, I was on an journalism internship there. And I got my first cat there, Maud. Apart from that, we shared a nice evening worship service from the blue hymnal. We've slated May 18 as the next one. We're going to draw on each other's expertise and different devotionals. So that'll be great. And my wife's cookies were a hit!
Sorrow: Asking for Forgiveness
I continually forget that I have a "congregation" that will need to receive my personal touch. We had very few people today, and part of that is because I have not kept up with my worshipping community. I'll be making some calls this week.
Hopefulness: Resolving to Grow
I'm hopeful that I can convey the wonder and beauty of our church's history through the Equip classes this week. The last 500 years have been very important, I think, in the history of the world, and we'll be talking about several men and women who have played an important part in the furthering of the kingdom of God on earth. I'm hopeful about the ministry plan that will come together this month. To God be the glory.
Thursday, May 1, 2014
Paper Part 4 and conclusion
The Return to Private Confession
This paper’s primary concern is not the cause of
private confession’s disappearance nor its status as a sacrament; the concern
is to return to the Reformer’s intention for Christians to go to private
confession when needful, for, as Luther famously said, “Therefore, when I urge
you to go to Confession, I am simply urging you to be a Christian.”[1]
Johnson maintains that the return of congregational
private confession begins with the pastor, but not in the form of sermons,
Bible studies, personal entreaties and blogs; the pastor first needs to go to confession.
Only the truly repentant can
convincingly preach repentance. Only the truly penitent can teach penance. Only
the confessor of sins can hear confession…If I as a pastor, desire to lead my
congregation in the recovery of a fruitful penitential practice, there is one
place to begin. I must go and kneel before a confessor, confess my sins to God
and beg for that glorious life-bearing Word: “I forgive you your sins in the
Name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit.[2]
A
local Lutheran pastor, who has been offering monthly confession for the past 22
years, said it took him thirteen years of preparation before he reinstituted
the sacramental rite in his congregation.[3] Rev. Ronald F. Marshall,
of First Lutheran in Seattle, offers confession from 3 to 5 pm on the third
Saturday of each month. [4] After outlining the
theological background for confession – we are terrible sinners; the wrath of
God is real and not a joke; the proper response by a sinner is contrition and
seeking true repentance; the saving power of Christ’s atonement; and finally
that the pastor is respected as “neither a courtier nor a hired hand, but God’s
servant and slave”[5]
– Marshall laid out a 15-point plan for
the sacrament of absolution.[6] Most Lutheran hymnals have
a form for private personal confession,[7] but Marshall does not
believe it is strong enough, and mandates Luther’s form for the rite;[8] nor was the hymnal’s
absolution powerful enough, so he substituted an Eastern Orthodox formula.[9] He sent this rite to the
congregation, discussed it with the church council and put forth his argument
in the newsletter. He announced he would be receiving absolution from a
neighboring pastor and a consistent time was posted. Marshall always wears his
clerical collar, black cassock and proper liturgical stole, befitting the
sobriety of the rite. He has invited local Episcopalian, Roman Catholic clergy
and laity to the sacrament.[10]
Pieper
simply says that “the public or veiled opposition [to confession] is overcome
if by public instruction from the pulpit or in voters’ meetings.” Piepkorn
claims that Lutherans have positioned themselves to be uniquely qualified to be
the center of a renewed interest in Absolution:
Lutheranism has the sanest and
most scriptural doctrine of confession of any church. We force no one to
enumerate his sins; we make confession contingent upon the individual’s
willingness…;we absolve without condition and without penance; yet, we can
offer personal, individual, operative absolution. We have all of confession’s
blessings, and none of its banes.[11]
Wiecher,
however, states that private confession in American Lutheran churches faces an
uphill battle precisely because of the cultural impasse we’re up against,
because “by its very form and practice, it was entirely antithetical to the
American democratic ideals and the individualistic ethos of established
American evangelical protestantism.”
Conclusion
Most
authors agree that private confession should be retained in the Lutheran
church, even though it may be “unnecessary.” [12] Getting Lutherans to the
point where they desire this is the challenge. In arguing for the inclusion of
Absolution into the Sacramental realm, Klan states:
The sacraments serve the lived
faith, that is, the faith that lives out of forgiveness; they become
crystallization points for a daily exercise in Christianity….[A]bsolution as a
God-given “sign” assists the believer to be sure of his salvation because God’s
self-commitment is carried out in an external and visible way.[13]
I
believe Lutherans will be drawn to confession not because we add it to our list
of sacraments, but because of our desire for an external, visible and audible sign of God’s love for us. While
it may be a “pseudo-sacrament,” it can still be a valuable assistant to the two
that we do have. Many Lutherans take the Lord’s Supper weekly, and of course
are asked to examine their souls and consciences before they do; but how many
use that time to look at what everyone’s wearing instead of examining their
consciences? Luther stated that
confession is “nothing but a way and a return to baptism,” but almost by
definition, Lutherans don’t remember their baptisms. If we follow Christ’s
logic of our own forgetfulness (“do this in remembrance of me”[14]) could not private
confession be that monthly reminder of us being buried and raised with Christ?
While
I appreciate the care and concern Marshall took in establishing private
confession in his Seattle church, I don’t believe the Marshall Plan is the only
way – 13 years preparation, 5 steps of confession, 15 consistent points,
clerical collar only. Likewise, I disagree with Piepkorn that a simple sermon
series on confession preached from the pulpit nor taking a vote in a voter’s
meeting, will also not do the trick.
Clearly,
the confessional pastor needs to go to confession. The next obvious step is to
begin teaching the rite to – and receiving the confession of – our church’s
elders. Our particular group of elders is extremely bonded and would be very
much open to this exercise. With very little training, they could then become
confessors as well. The next group would be the established leadership of both
adults and youth. Pastoral counseling should include an option for the
confessional rite, and by this point, when you have 40-50 people talking about
their changed lives, about the qualitative
difference between hearing a word of absolution corporately and naming your
sins to a fellow Christian and affirming the statement by your confessor: “Do
you believe that my forgiveness is God’s forgiveness?” [15] you have the beginning of
a confessional church.
[1] Gassman and Hendrix,
p. 107.
[3] Ronald
F. Marshall, “Salvation
Within Our Reach,”
in Whatever Happened to Private
Confession, Lutheran Forum, Vol. 31, No. 3, 1997, p.
18.
[4]Ronald F. Marshall, Website for
First Lutheran Church of West Seattle, last modified 2012, accessed April
25, 2014, http://www.flcws.org/worship.htm
[5] Marshall, “Salvation
within Our Reach,” p. 19-20
[7] William
S. Wiecher, “Piepkorn
on the Third Sacrament: An American Lutheran Reconsideration,” in Whatever Happened to Private Confession, Lutheran Forum, Vol. 31, No. 3, 1997,
p. 35.
[8] “Miserable person
that I am, I confess and lament to you before God that I am a sinful and weak
creature. I do not keep God’s commandments; I do not really believe the gospel;
I do nothing good; I cannot bear ill. (Especially have I committed…which
burdens my conscience.) I therefore ask that you, in God’s stead, would declare
to me my sins forgiven me and comfort me with the Word of God.” Marshall,
“Salvation within Our Reach, p. 21.
[9] “May God who
pardoned David through Nathan the prophet when he confessed his sins, and Peter
weeping bitterly for his denial, and the sinful woman weeping at his feet, and
the publican and prodigal son, may that same God forgive you all things,
through me a sinner, both in this world and in the world to come, and set you
uncondemned before his terrible judgment seat. Have no further care for the
sins which you have confessed. Depart in peace.” ibid.
[10] ibid.
[11] Wiecher, p. 34.
[12] “While private
confession and absolution are ‘unnecessary,’ they are a helpful gift that God
has given to us. We know that God has forgiven us all our sins, but Christians
frequently are troubled by specific sins. They need reassurance and confidence
that they are really forgiven. Satan constantly tempts us to doubt our
forgiveness and salvation. Private absolution gives us a powerful weapon and
reassurance as we hear a fellow Christian embody Christ’s commission to forgive.
They forgive us for specific sins in a concrete way. Christians receiving the
gift of absolution often describe it as a liberating and uplifting experience.
Certainly it is, because it is centered in the liberating and uplifting
Gospel.”Stephen P. Mueller, Called to
Believe, Teach, and Confess: An Introduction to Doctrinal Theology, Wipf and Stock, Eugene, Oregon,
2005, p. 322.
Paper Part 3
Absolution as a Sacrament
When asked what Luther’s chief gift to the church
was, Luther’s chief lieutenant, lawyer and friend Philip Melanchton said it was
Luther’s correct teaching and proper use of the Sacrament of Penance.[1] And yet it was Melanchton
who wished to retain private confession as a third sacrament in the foundling
church and Luther did not. Their dispute centered on their definition of what a
sacrament is. Luther wrote:
it has seemed proper to restrict
the name of sacrament to those promises which
have signs attached to them. The remainder, not being bound to signs, are
bare promises. Hence there are strictly speaking but two sacraments in the
church of God – baptism and the bread…The sacrament of penance, which I added
to these two, lacks the divinely instituted visible sign, and is, as I have
said, nothing but a way and a return to baptism.[2]
Luther thought of private confession as “salutary,
but not sacramental.” According to Rittgers, Luther considered it “a
pseudo-sacrament, a means of returning to the inexhaustible supply of grace one
received in baptism.”[3] Melanchton, meanwhile, in the Apology of the
Augsburg Confession, counts absolution as a sacrament of repentance, of being a
symbolic act as a witness of grace and the forgiveness of sins. He wrote in Article
XIII, “Therefore, the sacraments are actually baptism, the Lord’s Supper, and
absolution, (the sacrament of repentance). For these rites have the command of
God and the promise of grace, which is the essence of the New Testament.” [4] If Luther needed an
outward sign, then the laying on of hands by the priest to the penitent would
suffice.[5]
The argument over private confession took a
different turn in the German town of Nurnberg, where a famous preacher, Andreas
Osiander, considered private confession as the only valid confession, banning the
practice of corporate confession of
sins – “a congregational recitation of a confession of sin followed by a
clerical absolution spoken to the whole assembly”[6] – which was also widely
practiced and accepted by the Reformers. Osiander’s argument was that
“laypeople would not attend private confession if general confession were
practiced, because they would think the individual encounter with a pastor
redundant.” [7]
While both Luther and Melanchton were sympathetic to Osiander, saying that
private was superior to general confession, they agreed that both should be
retained in Nurnberg.[8]
Out of this storm came the conclusion that private
confession a) was not a sacrament b) was still commended, c) should not exclude
a general confession of sins. The Reformers agreed that private confession
should be retained as a practice for Christian living.
The Demise of Private Confession
So what happened to it?
Rittgers blamed Luther’s hedging. “Luther
contributed directly to Lutheranism’s uncertainty about the status of private
confession. For better of for worse, the new rite was his rite.” According to
Jeske and Kuhlman, in the years following the Reformation, the practice of private
confession waned due to a combination of
·
“familiarity breeds contempt”: Jeske concludes, “the institutionalization and
establishment of any Gospel-centered practice will eventually lead to some
abuse through negligence and indifference. So it was with private confession.”[9]
·
practicality:
The sheer enormity of one pastor – John Winkler, chief pastor in Hamburg –
confessing 30,000 people’s sins made a mockery of the rite.[10]
·
War:
The Thirty Years war decimated Lutheran territories, and many Lutheran churches
did not have pastors for those decades; naturally, confession fell into disuse.[11]
·
Pietism:
Its emphasis on individual’s confessing their sins to God alone instead of to
the pastor and his theory of the transformation of the inner man led Spener to
criticize it for its mechanical quality by 1670.[12] By 1698, the Elector of
Saxony ordered all confessionals removed from churches.[13]
·
Enlightenment:
Calling it “this unhappy remnant of the Roman enslavement of souls,” [14] private confession was
almost totally abandoned by the end of the 18th century. [15]
Johnson concludes, “The evident fact is,
contemporary Lutheranism lives in a combined state of ignorance and denial
concerning this ancient churchly practice commended at several places in the
Augsburg Confession and urged on us by the reformers and many faithful teachers
in our own day…true Confession and Absolution have not so much been reformed as
simply abandoned.” [16]
[1] Kuhlman, p. 29.
[3] ibid
[5] Werner
Klän,
“The ‘Third Sacrament’: Confession and Repentance in the Confessions of the
Lutheran Church,”
in
Heilvolle Wende - Buße und Beichte in der
evangelisch-lutherischen Kirche Oberurseler Hefte, Ergänzungsband 5,
edited by Werner Klän and Christoph Barnbrock, translated by Mathias Hohls, Göttingen: Edition
Ruprecht, 2010, p. 9.
[6] Rittgers, p. 315.
[9] Jeske, p. 3.
[13] Mark
A. Jeske, "The Practice of Private Confession and Absolution in the
Lutheran Church," essay file, Wisconsin
Lutheran Seminary Library, last
modified 2010, accessed February 6, 2014, http://www.wlsessays.net/node/1017, p. 4
[14]
Kuhlman, p. 31.
[16] Phillip
Max Johnson,
“Exposed by the Light: Confessing our Sin and Naming our Sins,” in Whatever Happened to Private Confession, Lutheran Forum, Vol. 31, No. 3, 1997,
p. 15
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)